Legal action against Expoberries, Alpine Fresh, and Berry Fresh relates to Sweet Karoline blackberries and Daniela raspberries

Berry marketer Driscoll’s says it plans to pursue legal action three companies – Expoberries, Alpine Fresh, and Berry Fresh – over two varieties it alleges were developed from plant material taken by a former employee of its Mexican breeding programme.
In a statement, the group said it had filed lawsuits against the firms in the Eastern District of Virginia, Delaware, and Southern District of Texas courts, in relation to blackberries marketed as Sweet Karoline and raspberries sold under the trademark Daniela.
Driscoll’s is understood to have alleged “theft and unauthorised use and commercialisation” of plant material it owned.
That material, it argues, was stolen by someone who used to work for its Mexico breeding programme and who, according to the company, “patented the varieties with himself as the sole inventor”.
It stated: “Independent DNA testing shows that Sweet Karoline is closely related to Driscoll’s varieties that existed in Driscoll’s test plots during the time the employee worked for Driscoll’s, and the variety the patent identifies as one of Sweet Karoline’s parents is not a parent.”
The complaints also allege that the breeding timeline described in the Sweet Karoline patent is “not consistent” with the variety having been developed after the employee left Driscoll’s in June 2013.
Driscoll’s has apparently asked the courts to recognise its rights in the varieties and their patents, along with damages and other relief sought in the complaints.
“Breeding a great berry takes many years of patient work by our breeders and a significant investment by the growers who rely on it,” commented CEO Brie Smith.
“We spent roughly two years trying to resolve this privately and did not take this step lightly. Our dispute is with those responsible for taking our genetics, not with the growers who planted these varieties in good faith,” she continued.
“We remain open to a fair resolution that gives those growers a path forward, but until this matter is resolved, the future of these varieties is uncertain. We are fully committed to protecting the work of our breeders and growers.”






